Winter 2022 science in the Bonner lab

 The Rothera 2022 wintering marine team had to take diving out of the equation this winter due to unforeseen circumstances. Diving is a tool that allows marine scientists to access their underwater office and conduct a range of data collection such as the deployment of underwater experiments, species collection, surveys of the seabed along a transect, the use of specialised equipment to measure species responses and much more. In order to gain an accurate understanding of what is happening in Antarctic marine environments, divers need to be up close and personal with their subject. We call this type of work ‘in situ’ observations.

DEBRA, our ROV

Other tools can also be used to sample the marine environment and contribute towards maintaining long term time series to document changes over the years. Remotely Operated Vehicles (ROVs) allow the exploration of marine environments and require a pilot to drive the underwater robot. Our ROV is called DEBRA, short for deep environment benthic research apparatus.  DEBRA can dive to depths way beyond our diving limit; our limit is 30 meters where our time permitted on the bottom is only 15 minutes. DEBRA can dive to 100 meters and can be fitted with a claw or a Go Pro and can stay at this depth for 3 hours! The claw is manoeuvrable in four axis so it can rotate, open and close. A series of underwater deployments were deployed in 2017 by marine biologist Ben Robinson. Rocks and Perspex settlement panels were set across three depths, 30, 60 and 100 m. The aim was to monitor the settlement of sessile (non-mobile) invertebrates and to make a comparison across different depths and compare species diversity between natural versus artificial substrate. Collecting samples which have been deployed for five years is exceptionally rare and presents its challenges. First, the ever imposing threat of icebergs threaten the integrity of these deployments. Icebergs have a deep keel and have the ability to scour the seabed and take any existing structures along with it. Second, DEBRA is deployed from a boat down to 100 meters on specific waypoints.

Louis Day driving the boat whilst DEBRA is deployed into the water, view from her front eye (a GoPro).

The boat and DEBRA are subject to wind and tide and great care has to be made to keep the boat in position using the GPS. A lapse in concentration can see the boat drifting off and in turn dragging Debra along the seabed, or worse, wrapping the long electrical tether around the spinning propellers. As the wind pushes the boat back and forth both the throttle and steering have to be constantly adjusted to keep the boat in position. The ROV tether is coiled on a reel at the bow of the boat and needs to be paid out or wound in as Debs descends or ascends - not enough line out will prevent her from moving and will transfer any movement from the boat straight to Debra and therefore makes her very difficult to control. Too much line can tangle around itself, Debra, rocks on the seabed or the boat engines. The weight of excess line can also pull her backwards as if being dragged by the boat.

Therefore, ROV operations must be conducted in calm conditions with little swell and wind below 10 knots. Many hours are spent searching for these underwater deployments which are marked with a 1m length of rope and a subsurface buoy. Upon location, the pilot uses precise movements to open the claw, inch forwards and pinch the subsurface rope. This is all visible on a controller screen which is connected to DEBRA via an electrical tether. The claw is closed and the sample is slowly hauled to the surface. Samples are then processed and analysed in the Bonner laboratory. In order to identify bryozoan species, the rocks and panels must be completely dry to distinguish between features. Multiple photos of the settlement panels are stitched together and allow the percentage cover of species to be assessed. Competition between species can be assessed between the panels across the depth transect.

An example of the samples DEBRA collected from 100m, settlement panels with a community of encrusting animals called bryozoans.

We continued to conduct the weekly CTD and water sampling events over our winter. The CTD measures conductivity (salinity), temperature and depth. It also measures pigment levels in the water, which shows how much phytoplankton there is, allowing an assessment of the water primary production. Productivity changes throughout the seasons with changing sunlight and sea ice. Collecting this data is extremely valuable to monitor long-term changes. The more phytoplankton in the water, the more food is available for larger organisms to feed, supporting complex food webs.  

 As we were not diving, the dive officer helped with the science side of the Bonner research. This included setting up a new project, conducting vertical plankton trawls in Ryder Bay. Different depths and times of year were sampled in order to assess any changes within the planktonic communities and populations. The data from this sampling showed a range of organisms in the water column and gives us more information of organism’s pelagic larval stages of their life cycle. Changes in organism abundancy could potentially be linked back to the phytoplankton levels in the water, as a food source, which are measured by the water sampling and CTD.           

                                           

                                           

                                                             

On board one of our RIBS, Erebus, with Louis Day as the Cox and Alice Clement using a winch to collect samples.

In addition to water sampling, biological long term time series involve the monthly collection of eight dominant invertebrate species. This time series began in 1997 and aim to document the reproductive patterns of marine invertebrates in response to environmental factors. For examples, questions such as ‘if waters warm, will invertebrates be more or less efficient at producing the next generation?’ can be answered. The utility of multiyear data will permit the identification of long term signals associated with climate change. Usually, divers would collect these animals from two sites in Ryder Bay. This year, we have used a combination of Van Veen grabs, to collect bivalves that burrow into the sediment and baited traps which attract brittle stars in particular. Furthermore, the subsurface rope that is used to mark deployments, collected using the ROV, provide an excellent settlement substrate for sea squirts and sea cucumbers. Species collected on theses ropes have also contributed towards the monthly species collection.

The marine team also participate in a project to monitor marine invertebrate feeding activity. Ordinarily, divers would swim along a pre-defined transect and visually record feeding in suspension feeders. The aim is to establish the timing of periods of feeding and non-feeding to relate the timing of summer feeding activity to that of the seasonal phytoplankton bloom and dynamics of winter sea ice .The switch from feeding to non-feeding can occur in a matter of weeks where a whole colony of sessile invertebrates could transition from feeding to not feeding and vice versa. 

 

A screen grab from benthic life at Beautiful Bulge

Another fantastic tool that can be deployed from our RIBS are Baited Remote Underwater Video Systems (BRUVS for short). These rigs are deployed either on the sea bed or mid water to sample fish assemblages and gather data about species which are otherwise mostly illusive when diving due the disturbance caused by divers.  Two camera are positioned at a fixed distance on each rig. Once a fish is identified during video playback, trigonometry can be used to calculate the length of the fish and hence give information about the structure of fish populations.

Screen-grab from a BRUV video!

In conclusion, the Bonner team has been able to fulfil key research goals without diving and continue to collect environmental and biological data to understand how changes will affect polar diversity. The outcome of this work will provide an insight into the impacts environmental change will have on the natural world and contribute towards future conservation measures.